The 5 Best Aftermarket Nerf Darts

To the undiscerning eye, the Nerf may appear as a mere plastic toy. But we know better, don’t we?

For all who have experienced the kinetic thrill of firing a Nerf Blaster can testify that it is, in fact, a true feat of engineering – and one that is not complete without the proper ammunition.

Just for you, we have compiled for you a list of the five best aftermarket Nerf darts out there.

Our top Choice

X-Shot Excel Universally Compatible Foam Darts Refill Pack (100 Darts) by ZURU

Shorter - Faster and ave proven to shoot farther than others. 

Bad news is that they don't fit all models of Nerf guns. Depending on the gun you have, these would be a greta option or they won't fit.  

4.5 of 5 Stars

Why Aftermarket?

Nerf is a brand that is not only famous for its engineering ingenuity but also notorious for its premium pricing.

Its slogan, which has become a source of many a meme, is after all, “It’s Nerf or Nothin!”.

But not all of us can afford to hash out large amounts of money to sustain this hobby of ours. Thus, many turn to aftermarket products as affordable alternatives, albeit sometimes at the expense of quality.

And that’s exactly why this article is here. We’ll make sure you get the most out of your buck with these aftermarket darts, for their quality is, if not better, than comparable at the very least, to that of Nerf’s own product line, while also being significantly more affordable.

With that being said, these aftermarket products may not be suitable for those looking for darts to use with their Nerf Ultra Blasters

The Wall Street Journal reported that this new line of blasters is designed only to work with Nerf’s new line of darts. No exceptions. Not yet.

However, I wouldn’t worry too much about it if I were you. Third-party producers usually don’t take long before finding a way around such matters. Aftermarket is a wondrous place and a very reactive one at that.

Basic of Selection

In order to sieve through the multitudes of options and present to you only the best of the best, we focused on factors that have been deemed to be of utmost importance to Nerfers around the world – distance, impact, durability, and precision.

Regarding the factor of precision, it is one of nuance, where it differs from the traditional aspect of accuracy. What this means is that it is based not on how closely the darts land to where it is being aimed, but on how tight the grouping of the shots is.

This was done on the stance that you can easily control for inaccuracy by adjusting your personal aim, but when it comes to bad precision, there exists no reliable remedy.

It should also be noted that precision and distance have often been found to be inversely related.

The rest of the factors are rather straight-forward. So, without further ado, here are the best aftermarket darts out there:

Little Valentine 400-Dart Refill Pack for Nerf N-Strike Elite

The Little Valentine Darts seem to be the aftermarket staple for many Nerfers.

Distance covered by these darts have been said to be remarkable, and its precision rivals that of Nerf’s own Accustrike Darts.

As for impact, it hits harder than average, which makes for more fun for some but should be avoided by those easily bruised.

Little Valentine 400-Dart Refill Pack for Nerf N-Strike Elite
  • Refill Pack includes 400 Little Valentine darts(7.2*1.3cm)
  • Darts work with any N-Strike Elite blaster (sold separately)
  • Also work with most original N-Strike blasters (sold separately)
  • WARNING: The tip is made of plastic to ensure shoot farther, so please don't shoot at kids under ten directly. Wear eye protection! Let the battle begin!
  • Standard Packaging Includes 400 Little Valentine darts(This is 3rd party darts)

The Little Valentine Dart is best known for its durability, and the words – Little Valentine – are printed on the body of the dart and make for a simple and deceivingly adorable aesthetic. At the current price point, the Little Valentine Darts is definitely a steal.

It is also renowned for its compatibility with most Nerf Blasters and grants the smoothest firing. Jamming rates report at about once per 200 shots, with some users claiming that it has not jammed their slingfire even once, and that’s saying something.

Blaster Darts, NextX 300 Pack Refill Bullets for Nerf N-Strike Elite, Toys Foam Blasters for Boys Party Favors, With Portable Storage Bag

These blaster darts from NextX have been said to be indistinguishable from those produced by Nerf, both in quality and in its aesthetics. 

Distance and impact of NextX darts are said to be on par with that of Nerf’s Elite Darts, with durability that surpasses it.

They are heavier, harder, and more streamlined, which makes for longer distances, higher impact, and better durability.

Blaster Darts, NextX 300 Pack Refill Bullets for Nerf N-Strike Elite, Toys Foam Blasters for Boys Party Favors, With Portable Storage Bag
  • Nerf Mate For Shoot: Every refill blaster darts use Non-toxic and Anti-friction EVA Toy Foam Blasters darts in the parcel. Faster and Farther, Accurate, Sufficient for a pint-sized battle.The refill darts can be Used again and again.
  • Rush To Battlefield: Blaster Darts are compatible with any N-Strike Elite blaster, The blaster darts is frustration-free shoots nerf blaster darts up to 90 feet (27 meters) in Nerf N Strike Elite series.lighter,farther darts for battle
  • Darts Of NextX Ammo: Includes 300 pcs of Nerf darts, each of darts designed with a "hole", The hole of darts for dumb air release, and come to enough ammo for extensive Nerf battles and wars. Never be out of Nerf bullets darts ever again!
  • Large Pack, Continued Fire: 30 prepackages of ammo in packs of ten Nerf Bullets, open up one package at a time. Also ships in a simple recyclable carrier bag, that's easy to storage and carry outdoor the nerf bullets for battle.
  • Toy Foam Blaster darts for Nerf War Party: Designed for refill bullets ammo, Sufficient for nerf war, compatible to Nerf N-Strike Elite, tested and approved for performance and quality darts, and constructed of foam with flexible, hollow tips, keep Fighting!

Although these darts are said to be slightly less precise than those from Nerf, what it lacks in precision it makes up for in great affordability.

If you’re looking to supply a Nerf war, NextX is a perfect choice.

Dart Zone 300 Sureshot Waffle-Tip Darts - Refill Pack for All and Most Standard NERF Dart Blasters by Prime Time Toys, 300 pc

The Dart Zone Sureshot Waffle-Tip Darts differ from the former two products in its lack of recognition.

These darts, as its name suggests, is known for its immaculate precision. In terms of distance, these darts do not lose out to those of Little Valentine’s or NextX’s, covering distances of up to 90ft.

Dart Zone 300 Sureshot Waffle-Tip Darts - Refill Pack for All and Most Standard NERF Dart Blasters by Prime Time Toys, 300 pc
  • (300) Dart Zone Official Waffle-Tip Super Darts
  • Super Darts Fly up to 90 Feet!
  • Universal Darts work with Dart Zone blasters and most blasters from major brands
  • Ages 8+

It is also made to be more child-friendly and has a softer impact than the average dart. Its relative lack of acclaim is likely due to its slightly higher price when compared to the usual Accufakes and Waffles.

Dart Zone Sureshot Waffle-Tip Darts still provide the buyer with great value, fitting and firing smoothly in all blasters and ensuring a consistency in spread and precision that is unrivaled by any other, be it Nerf or other aftermarket brands.

BOOMCO. Dart 40-Pack, Green with Black Tip

The BOOMCO. Darts are designed to be simple and all-rounded in nature. They have been found to be more precise and a lot more durable than those produced by Nerf.

The BOOMCO. Darts are not known for performing particularly well in any one given area, but the consensus is that they are simply more cost-effective versions of Nerf Darts due to both a lower price and a higher quality.

BOOMCO. Dart 40-Pack, Green with Black Tip
  • HaveABlast with BOOMco.!
  • Tip of every dart is made of BOOMco.'s Smart Stick material
  • Sticks to all Smart Stick targets and blaster shields
  • Available in 3 different colors so you can recognize yours on the battlefield (sold separately)
  • 40 Smart Stick darts per pack

These darts also stick to certain surfaces and thus, make good darts for target practice. They have been reported by to travel slightly longer distances than Nerf Darts while also having a softer impact.

X-Shot Excel Universally Compatible Foam Darts Refill Pack (100 Darts) by ZURU

Though these darts are not compatible with several models of Nerf Blasters due to its shorter length, it’d be a sin not to include it in this list. These Darts have won the Best Dart Range Award for three consecutive years.

The X-Shot Darts are engineered to shoot further, faster, and more accurately. Durability is an area where it does not, pun intended, excel in. But it is a small price to pay for experiencing just how quickly these darts fly through the air.

X-Shot Excel Universally Compatible Foam Darts Refill Pack (100 Darts) by ZURU
  • Compatible with all major leading blaster brands
  • Dart-Range Award

The X-Shot Darts are slightly pricier than the other mentioned brands. But at the same time, it presents something that the other alternatives do not possess, and will be a great addition to your ammunition if you’re looking to spice things up a little.


And that’s a wrap! These are the five best aftermarket Nerf darts out there. 

So get your blast on, fellow Nerfers. And have a blast while you’re at it.